Lebanon Breaks Israel’s World Record for Hummus

October 27, 2009

To further their claims to intellectual property rights for hummus, as a Lebanese dish, 300 chefs in Beirut prepared a dish of hummus weighing 2056kg, by mixing 1360kg of mashed chickpeas, 333 litres of lemon juice and 26kg of salt to break the World record for the largest plate of the dip, that was established last May be Israel.

The Lebanese then went on to prepare a tabbouleh salad that weighed in at 3538kg and included 1596kg of parsley, 1496kg of tomatoes and 419kg of onions.

Actually, I view this development in a positive light. I think that if national pride and the Arab Israel Conflict could be redirected to fighting over world records instead of lobbing scuds and artillery shells over the fence, it is in everyone’s interest.


Arab Strategy Forum to Focus on Intellectual Property Rights

October 26, 2009

The Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum Foundation has announced that 30 intellectuals and 200 thought-leaders will provide critical insights into the state of intellectual property rights and its role in the region’s economy, at the first in a series of seminars to mark the Arab Strategy Forum, a crucial platform for policy makers to network and share expertise on economic, geopolitical, social and cultural issues.

To be held in Dubai, the session titled ‘Transfer or indigenisation (sic) of knowledge?’ will define the second day of the event that will be held on 28th and 29th of October.

The discussions will apparently throw light on the legislative, organizational, cultural, and material requirements for intellectual property rights and will specifically examine the extent of Arab contributions to the development of the international conventions on property rights.

For more information: http://www.ameinfo.com/213654.html

We wonder if our good friend Dr. Amir Khoury of Tel Aviv University will attend and hope the event does not turn into another fiasco trying to copyright Hummous and the pyramids.

Come to think of it, as of tomorrow, I am expecting to pass the 100,000 reader mark on this blog, which makes me far and away the region’s most popular writer on IP issues. Although, not a major IP writer by Jewish standards, with a much smaller readership than either, say, Professor David Nimmer or Professor Jeremy Philips, nevertheless, as the Middle East’s number 1 IP blogger, who faithfully tries to cover IP events in Arab countries, I’d have expected an all expense paid, complimentary trip  to this conference. Ah well.

Still, it would be nice if the Arab States decide to allow Israeli companies to register trademarks there. It would be nice if, 15 years after signing a peace treaty, Jordan would allow Israeli companies to register patents…


Jordanian Patent Attorney Association Boycotts Israel

May 30, 2009

Charles Shaban of AGIP writes as follows:

In respect of cooperation. I regret to advise you that the Jordanian Attorneys Syndicate ruled that any attorney dealing with Israel will be subject to cancellation of his license to practice and in fact the Syndicate has proceeded to disbar certain lawyers. Since our firm incorporates several Jordanian attorneys, we have been advised that if we deal with Israeli companies, we will be jeopardizing the licenses of our attorneys.

It is not the first time we have come across this unofficial boycott. Some of our clients, particularly pharmaceutical manufacturers, file in Jordan, and have had applications abandoned.  Officially, after a historic peace treaty signed between the Late King Hussain and the Late Prime Minister, Itzhak Rabin, there is a normalization of relations between Israel and Jordan. 

In this instance, it is Jordan that loses out. Israeli science and engineering is more advanced than that or her neighbors, but labor is cheaper in the surrounding Arab states. A normalization of relationships between Israel and Jordan would result in closer economic cooperation that is more important to Jordan than to Israel.

Of course, this should be dealt with on a political level. It does not help that when the Special 301 Report published, Ben Eliezer (Fuad) the Minister of Trade and Industry has announced his ignorance of IP issues.  One also wonders where WIPO is.


Cheesed Off

April 20, 2009

According to our friends, the IPKat The (London) Times reports that attempts to get appelation of origin for Red Leicester cheese have come to a halt after the main makers could not agree on the recipe. See http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/food_and_drink/article6127902.ece

 Specifically, David and Jo Clarke and Long Clawson dairy can’t agree on whether a starter, commonly used in Swiss cheeses should be included. Yes, says Long Clawson, but no say the Clarkes, who insist that the addition of the starter alters the flavour of the cheese. It appears therefore that the application is now on hold, although the local councillor, Mr O’Callaghan, hopes that the process will eventually go ahead. ‘The most difficult part of the whole process in applying for protection is agreeing what you are trying to protect’ he is quoted as saying.

It would appear, therefore, that to be protectable as a food from a specific region, a distinctive taste and a standard recipe are required. One hopes that this will stop Lebanese attempts to monopolize humus. However, as the Anti Racism conference shows, where Israel is concerned, double standards are applied.


Appelation of Origin for Hummus and Other Arab Dishes

December 15, 2008

President of the Lebanese Industrialists’ Association, Fadi Abboud, has argued that hummus is a Lebanese product.

Apparently, Talal Abu-Ghazaleh, chairman and founder of Jordan-based IP group Talal Abu-Ghazaleh Organization (TAGorg), has stated to World Trademark Review that “If it is made using Lebanese ingredients and a Lebanese recipe it should be sold as Lebanese hummus not Israeli hummus.”

“I’m not claiming or assuming that Lebanon has ownership of the production itself, rather that it has rights in the geographic name.”

Thus according to my learned, Jordanian colleague, it would appear that either Hummus is a Lebanese place name, or the problem is that Israel has been marketing Lebanese Hummus.

Ms. Hoda Barakat , managing partner and head of the IP department at Dubai-based Al Tamimi & Company (presumably no relation to the Baraket at Reinhold Cohn’s Law Office?), notes that although many Arab states do not have specific GI laws, GIs are often protected as certification marks under trademark legislation.

Abu-Ghazaleh is apparently working to harmonize and strengthen the current systems, campaigning for more robust IP rights across the Arab world.

As Abu Ghazaleh is based in Jordan, a state with diplomatic relations with Israel, here’s a suggestion: why not work to normalize trade relations with Israel? Particularly, work to allow Israeli companies to register trademarks in Arab states and international companies to do so without having to declare fulfilling the Arab boycott. Then, claims for special rights for national dishes and the like, could be examined in a normalized business atmosphere.


Iranian Artists Call for Tougher Copyright Protection

December 15, 2008

According to the Tehran Times, the Inranian Artists forum held a conference on copyright as part of the Fajr International Music Festival.

Law expert Hassan Mirhosseini who attended the seminar claimed that that the law protecting intellectual property rights was approved by the Iranian parliament in 1970. “We have problems in execution of the law in Iran and unfortunately, the law is not protected by any sanctions. There is no official organization to prosecute the offenders and people are generally unaware of these laws,” he stated.

Apparently, the law allows for three years imprisonment for copyright infringement. It is not clear however, whether this includes downloading music tracks for private use, or commercially playing them.


Lebanese Group Seeks to Reclaim Hummus as National Food

October 9, 2008

Hummus, a savoury dip made from chickpeas with olive oil, spices and often flavoured with tehina Read the rest of this entry »


Kuwait Holds Intellectual Property Seminar

March 11, 2008

Kuwait is holding its first Intellectual Property Seminar. See: 

http://www.kuwaittimes.net/read_news.php?newsid=NTc5MDk2Njkz

We view these developments with hope, and trust that the Kuwait IP Office recognizes filings from Israel, or at least do not require declaration of suport for the Arab boycott as precondition for protection.


Iraq Waives Israel Boycott Declaration Requirement

February 21, 2008

It is apparently now possible to get trademark registrations in Iraq without declaring compliance with the Israel Boycott.

See Read the rest of this entry »


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 103 other followers