C.T.S. LTD filed Israel trademark application numbers 2253382 and 253359 “Lactofil” and לקטופיל. The Mark covers Cosmetic preparations namely lotions, creams, mousses and soaps for nourishment and cleaning of the skin and face all in Class 3. “” Laboratorios Genesse, S.L. opposes the marks
Meanwhile, Laboratorios Genesse, SL. has filed Israel trademark application number 249389 for Lactivit for Soaps, gels, perfumery, essential oils, cosmetics, lotions for hair and skin care, creams for hair and skin care, and dentifrices also in Class 3. C.T. S. LTD are opposing this registration.
Both parties propose combining the hearings. The Lactofil hearing was scheduled for 29 October 2014.
The legal issue in both cases is likelihood of confusion with the similar product of the other party. The parties and the issues in both cases is the same. Combining the cases saves the parties time and expense, and saves judicial resources. In one case there are additional claims of inequitable behavior, but this is not seen as sufficient justification to hear the cases separately.
As both parties have equal rights, Ms Yaara Shoshani, Adjudicator at the Israel Patent and Trademark Office ruled the cases are to be combined, however in each case, at the combined hearing, the Opposer has the right to cross-examine the applicant’s witnesses and only then may the Opposer’s witnesses be cross-examined.
In the circumstances, no costs were awarded.
Decision to Combine Similar Trademark Proceedings, Yaara Shoshani Caspi 6 October 2014.
Apart from the parties in question, there is a third party of importance, i.e. the public. It seems to me that combining the proceedings is not only economical for the parties and for the public purse in terms of judicial expense, but also is most likely to result in a sensible ruling.