I try to be factually accurate and helpful to my readership. However, occasionally mistakes happen. A couple of days ago I posted about the Third International Conference on the Economics of Innovation to be held in Israel under the auspices of the AIPPI in Israel between 30 April and 1 May 2018.
I received a press-release from the Israel Patent Office with a link to the website of the conference, so took details from there. I noted that the opening speakers were two Israel Nobel Laureates:
- Prof. Ada Yonat, The Martin S. and Helen Kimmel Professor of Structural Biology.
- Prof. Aaron Ciechanover, Technion
I commented that both were certainly eminent scientists in their fields, but if the conference organizers want Nobel Laureates to talk about the Economics of Innovation, one or both of Israel’s Nobel Laureates in Economics would be a better choice.
I’d like to think that the conference organizers follow my advice, and I do note that some of my criticisms of the first and second International Conferences have been addressed this time around, but I doubt that within a couple of days of my posting my criticism, the organizers would disinvite two such distinguished speakers. Nevertheless, they are not coming.
Instead the current program as advertised has a video greeting from Mr. Francis Guri [sic], WIPO president – a gimmick I enjoyed at a premiere cercle IP conference last year. Watching a VIP on-screen is not that exciting as in the flesh, and to be honest, I don’t think there is a major demand for autographs from WIPO presidents. (Indeed, when I was Guest of Honour at the AIPPI International Conference in Paris a few years back, I don’t recall anyone asking me for my autograph). Nevertheless, we assume that Francis Gurry (which is the correct spelling and should be corrected in the program) is perfectly competent to give an informed lecture on various aspects of IP. We suspect however, that his words of welcome will be more platitudes than substance.
The opening session is instead being given by Judge (retired) Asher Grunis, President of the Supreme Court of Israel 2012 – 2015 on “Judge made law in the field of intellectual property”. Judge Gronis gave several IP decisions over his long and illustrious career, such as Toffiffee, Adidas, Dior, Shemesh restaurants, Balugan – Spinmaster, etc.
Judge Grunis’ talk is being followed by one by Mr. Aharon Aharon, CEO, Israel Innovation Authority. The title of Mr. Aharon Aharon’s talk is not published in the program, but it is clear that he has some influence over Israel govt. policy regarding promoting innovation.
I view the change of opening speakers favorably, as both should have something to say that is relevant to IP issues which may well not be the case with Nobel laureates in science, despite their eminence in their fields.
The second mistake in Sunday’s post, noted by both IP KAT and leading Israel Trademark Attorney, Neil Wilkof, and by Patent Attorney David Silver, was that I put the price for Israelis which is 1600 Shekels down as $1600 by mistake. I have corrected that typo is Sunday’s post.